How to Avoid High Recruitment Agency Fees - Hiring People (2024)

We all know that recruitment agencies like to take a sizeable commission when finding you a successful candidate for your role. While some companies view this as an essential or unavoidable expense considering the benefits of time and convenience, there might just be another way to hire the perfect candidate with all the benefits, but at a much lower cost. However, before we look into alternative recruitment advertising solutions, it’s important to understand the business models recruitment agencies use.

How Do Recruitment Agencies Charge Their Clients?

Did You Know? Recruitment Agency Fees Can Be As High As 30%

For example: If you recruited a candidate on a £50k salary with the support of a recruitment company you could be charged £10k (20%) in recruitment fees. This is palatable if the candidate goes on to be a successful member of your company, but what if it doesn’t go according to plan?

Keep in mind this excludes any other fees such as car allowance, bonuses and retainers.

For a detailed look at recruitment agency charges, read How Much Do Recruitment Agencies Charge?

Other Problems When Using Recruitment Agencies

When agreeing to terms with your recruitment partner, there is normally a rebate period, but what if the candidate leaves after 3 months? You may have paid nearly £10k to the recruitment company, given up your time to recruit this ‘ideal candidate’ & provided support with the employee induction. On top of this, the employee would have been paid their salary and when you consider the total investment made, it’s hard to fathom that you may need to start your recruitment processes all over again.

Recruitment Agency Business Models

Some agencies will operate on different business models, for example some agencies will take a smaller percentage of the salary over several months, while others will charge based on hours worked, & performance. You can also have a recruitment agency fee based on a monthly retainer. This leads us nicely on to the alternative recruitment business model, flat fee recruitment.

Avoid High Recruitment Costs With Flat Fee Recruitment:

The flat fee recruitment business model is a low cost alternative to using an agency. With a flat fee recruiter, you or your hiring manager are in control. You write the job description (we have a large library of job description templates for you to choose from) and upon placing the job ad, you decide the level of exposure you want your job advert to receive with our fixed cost job advertising services.

The Benefits Of Flat Fee Recruitment

It’s Cheaper Than Agency Recruitment Fees

For example: You can pay a fixed amount to promote your job advert across various job boards and social media sites (both well known and niche job sites). If you were to use all the services offered by a fixed cost recruitment company, typically the cost would be £1,200, but you can recruit quality candidates for any position, in any location, across any industry for as little as £200. This is significantly greater value and cost efficient when you consider doing this with the job boards directly would comfortably cost over £1,200 or the cost of doing this with an agency.

Find Passive Candidates

If you want to source candidates who are passive in the market, or attract job seekers who didn’t apply for the job, you can instruct the recruiter to do a social search across platforms like LinkedIn, or request them to research the job board databases. These CV databases often come at a large cost so by working with fixed fee recruiters you gain a further discount, making your recruitment process even more cost effective.

Freedom & Flexibility

At different stages of the recruitment process, the choice is yours. As mentioned, you can just place an advert on all the job boards, you can search for candidates across social media and the job boards. The recruiter can filter CVs for you, engage with suitable candidates and qualify them, set up interviews and even close job offers or, should you prefer, you can do the parts of the recruitment process that you prefer to do. In a nutshell, you have the control to choose the right recruitment strategy, whether you want to save time or reduce costs.

Prepare to interview suitable applicants for you job vacancy by visiting our interviews hub for employers.

Filter The Best Candidates

The likely outcome is that you will have had lots of applicants to choose from and if this is the case, you may want the recruiter to filter through and identify the best candidates to approach. For most requirements, typically you want about 40 applicants and to target 5 people to interview. That’s where our free recruitment software comes in handy!

Free Recruitment Software (ATS)

This helps you drive your recruitment process by managing the applicants. You would have also built a talent pool of candidates because of your endeavours and this is your talent pool, meaning you can recruit as many candidates from the campaign as you wish, for no extra cost. We discus how to attract candidates and build talent pools in our article Creating A Talent Pool.

Read Centralising Recruitment With ATS.

So Why Isn’t Everyone Doing This?

Larger companies don’t need to as they have direct recruiters working for them who focus on CTR (Cost to Recruit) and TTR (Time to Recruit) and they use software and discounted job adverts to help them hit their targets.

In fact, the fixed cost recruitment model is geared towards SME’s who want to benefit from the discount and software that the corporates benefit from, but without the high typical fees.

So no, not everyone is doing this, but it is becoming common practice for all type of positions, both junior and senior, where small and medium sized businesses want to save recruitment costs.

Should You Still Work With Your Traditional Recruiter?

If your recruitment agency has a network and access to people who you don’t think are accessible elsewhere, then most definitely you should continue to work with them.

If you feel the candidates that you are trying to attract are online, either because they are looking for work or they are on social media, then the most cost-effective way to source candidates and keep recruitment costs low, is by placing an advert across all the job boards with a flat fee recruitment company.

It’s quick, easy and there is a strong chance you will be able to recruit a highly sought-after candidate because that person is searching online and, as you know if you are buying a car, shopping, booking a holiday or getting insurance quotes, you typically do this online; finding a job is no different.

How To Get Started

If you are new to the process, take a look at our job description templates to ensure you only attract the best candidates, take a look at our job advertising packages, and get in touch with a member of our sales team and together we will find a promotional package that’s perfect for you.

Happy hunting!

Next, read A Guide On How To Hire Employees orAlternative Ways To Advertise A Job.

How to Avoid High Recruitment Agency Fees - Hiring People (2024)

FAQs

How can recruiting costs be reduced? ›

Top 10 Ways To Reduce Recruitment Costs In 2024
  1. Prioritise Quality Over Quantity of Candidates.
  2. Cut Expenditure on Job Boards.
  3. Utilise Social Media to Attract Candidates.
  4. Choose Automation Over External Recruiting Agencies.
  5. Schedule Online Interviews.
  6. Encourage Employee Referrals.
  7. Maintain a Talent Pool.

What is the most common mistake organizations make with recruiting? ›

Here's our list of 10 common recruitment mistakes.
  • Relying too much on the interview.
  • Using unconscious bias.
  • Hiring people less qualified than you.
  • Rejecting an overqualified candidate.
  • Waiting for the perfect candidate.
  • Rushing the hire.
  • Relying too much on references.
  • Expecting too much, too soon from a new recruit.

Can you negotiate with a recruitment agency? ›

The first step in successfully negotiating fees and rates is to know your market and to be properly equipped with the right information. This includes: The typical recruitment agency fees in your geographic area and in your specific niche.

What steps should companies take during the hiring process to ensure that such bad hires do not happen? ›

How do you avoid a bad hire?
  • Avoid bad hires with accurate job descriptions. ...
  • Market to the appropriate target audience to avoid attracting a bad hire. ...
  • Spot a bad hire during the applicant review process. ...
  • Adapt your interview process to avoid a bad hire. ...
  • Don't rush the hiring process to avoid bad hires.

How do you reduce cost in an organization? ›

10 ways to reduce your business costs
  1. Explore an alternative place of business.
  2. Draw up a budget and stick to it.
  3. Move marketing online.
  4. Pool your equipment with other businesses (or barter)
  5. Use part-time and freelance staff.
  6. Don't automatically renew premiums and services.
  7. Avoid unnecessary charges for finance.

How can organizations reduce their HR costs? ›

HR Teams can generate savings on compensation costs by helping to rationalize employee counts across the organization. It includes temporary workforce reduction measures, restructuring as well as layoff management.

What are two things a recruiter would view negatively? ›

“A hiring manager wants to see if you represent yourself in a professional way.” To come off in the most positive pre-meeting light, “you will want to avoid using profanity, sexual or drug references,” Crawford says.

What is the biggest challenge in recruitment? ›

The most common recruiting challenges and how to overcome them
  • Attracting the right candidates.
  • Engaging qualified candidates.
  • Hiring fast.
  • Using data-driven recruitment.
  • Building a strong employer brand.
  • Ensuring a good candidate experience.
  • Recruiting fairly.
  • Creating an efficient recruiting process.

What is an unethical recruiter? ›

One of the obvious examples of ethical issues in recruitment is a recruiter who actually recruits from his own client base. Sure, that recruiter places candidates at Company A. But he also recruits employees away from Company A to work at Company B.

Do recruiters get commission if you get hired? ›

Most external recruiters make money based on a commission structure. The commission is usually a percentage of the total fees from a candidate's first-year base salary, or it can be a flat fee offered by the client (the company the candidate is placed in). This structure is generally established by the client.

Do recruiters expect you to negotiate? ›

Employers expect you to negotiate.

In fact, they will often have ~3-5% “cushion” pre-approved. They do this based on the assumption that you will ask for more. And if you do, it will save them from having to put your offer through the entire approval process again.

How do you ensure a fair hiring process? ›

  1. Write inclusive job ads.
  2. Communicate your policy.
  3. Establish clear selection criteria.
  4. Focus on assessing the relevant skills and competencies.
  5. Assemble diverse hiring panels.
  6. Standardize your interviews.
  7. Have a fair background checking process.
  8. Train interviewers.

What is the highest cost attributed to wrong hires? ›

A bad hire can cost you up to 30% of the employee's first-year earnings. — US Department of Labor. The average cost per hire is nearly $4,700. — Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM)

How do you deal with recruitment issues? ›

Here's how to overcome hiring challenges:
  1. Switch your approach from reactive to proactive.
  2. Create a consistent candidate experience.
  3. Develop a recruiting culture.
  4. Use Recruiting Metrics to Identify Opportunities for Improvement.
  5. Gather Feedback From Candidates And Hiring Managers.
  6. Consolidate Recruitment Technology.

Which method of recruitment is the most cost effective? ›

Employee referrals

Referral programs combine both internal and external recruitment strategies, where current employees are encouraged to refer potential candidates for open positions. This approach is highly beneficial as it is not only cost-effective but also fast.

Which method is one of the least expensive recruitment systems? ›

The word of mouth system • This method of recruitment is found to be effective in local situations . It is one of the least expensive recruitment systems . As soon as people learn that there's a job opening , the word spread around .

What may be included in recruiting cost? ›

These may include your recruiters' salaries, interview costs, employee referral bonuses and money you spend on training your hiring team. The external recruitment costs refer to any payment made to external vendors associated with your recruitment process.

How could a reduced cost create a competitive advantage? ›

It allows businesses to offer lower prices to secure greater volumes and/or extract higher margins than competitors. Lower costs, like prohibitive switching costs for customers, can often to boost firms' dominance in an industry.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. An Powlowski

Last Updated:

Views: 6114

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. An Powlowski

Birthday: 1992-09-29

Address: Apt. 994 8891 Orval Hill, Brittnyburgh, AZ 41023-0398

Phone: +26417467956738

Job: District Marketing Strategist

Hobby: Embroidery, Bodybuilding, Motor sports, Amateur radio, Wood carving, Whittling, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Prof. An Powlowski, I am a charming, helpful, attractive, good, graceful, thoughtful, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.